Kitchen Countertop Replacement: What You Need to Know


Kitchen island with Carrara marble kitchen countertop replacement, nickel plated faucet, rinse sink and white cabinets.

Getting new countertops can completely transform the look and functionality of your kitchen, but knowing where to start can feel overwhelming. Whether you’re upgrading your countertops to match new cabinets or want a fresh, modern look, a kitchen countertop replacement is a great way to revitalize your space. Let’s walk through everything you need to know about this important part of kitchen remodeling so you can approach the process with confidence.

What is the Best Material to Use for Kitchen Countertops?

Functional home design: Farmhouse style kitchen with wood ceiling beams

Selecting the right countertop material for your kitchen depends on your style, budget, and how you plan to use the space. From luxurious marble to durable stainless steel, each material offers its own unique set of benefits and drawbacks. Let’s explore some of the top materials available for your kitchen countertop replacement project and what you need to consider for each.

Marble

Marble is known for its timeless beauty and elegance. It brings a natural, luxurious feel to any kitchen and is available in a range of colors and veining patterns. However, keep in mind that it’s prone to scratching and staining, making it a higher-maintenance option. Marble requires regular sealing and careful use to maintain its appearance.

Quartz

Its non-porous nature makes quartz resistant to staining, and it’s one of the most durable options available. It doesn’t need to be sealed like natural stone and is available in a wide variety of colors and patterns. However, quartz can be pricey, and it may not offer the same natural look that materials like granite or marble provide.

Granite

Granite is incredibly durable, heat-resistant, and adds a natural, high-end aesthetic to your kitchen. Each slab is unique, offering one-of-a-kind beauty. Like marble, though, granite needs to be sealed periodically to avoid stains. It can also be high-cost, depending on the type you choose.

Soapstone

Another non-porous option, soapstone is resistant to bacteria and stains. Its smooth texture and unique veining offer a softer, more rustic look. Soapstone can scratch easily, though, and develop a patina over time, which might not be ideal for everyone.

Concrete

Customizable in terms of color and finish, concrete countertops can be shaped to fit any kitchen layout. They offer a modern, industrial look. Keep in mind, though, that concrete is prone to cracking over time and requires regular sealing to prevent stains and moisture damage.

Solid Surface

Solid surface countertops, like Corian, offer a seamless look and are available in many colors. They’re easy to clean and relatively low maintenance. However, these countertops can scratch or burn easily, and while they can be repaired, they may not be as durable as stone options.

Ceramic Tile

Ceramic tile is a budget-friendly option that comes in many colors, shapes, and patterns. It’s heat-resistant and easy to install. One drawback of these tiles, however, is that the grout can be difficult to clean, and tiles can crack under heavy impact.

Butcher Block

Offering a warm, natural look to your kitchen, butcher block countertops are ideal for food prep. The material is also relatively affordable compared to other countertop materials. Some drawbacks, though, are that butcher block requires regular maintenance, such as oiling, to keep it in good condition. It can also scratch and stain easily.

Stainless Steel

If you want a professional-looking and minimalist-vibe kitchen, stainless steel countertops are the way to go. Heat-resistant, durable, and hygienic, they’re a popular choice in high-end restaurant kitchens. Stainless steel also offers a sleek, modern look. However, stainless steel can dent and scratch easily, and it shows fingerprints and smudges more than other materials.

Laminate

One of the most affordable options for countertops, laminate comes in a wide variety of colors and patterns, mimicking the look of natural materials. But laminate can be easily damaged by heat and sharp objects, and it’s not as durable as other options like stone or quartz.

The Kitchen Countertop Replacement Process

Custom home remodeling.

Replacing your kitchen countertops isn’t a one-day job, but with proper planning, the process can go smoothly. Here’s what you can expect from a typical kitchen countertop replacement project:

  1. Initial Consultation & Material Selection: The first step involves meeting with a professional at Pathway Design Build to discuss your options and select your new countertop material. Your kitchen space will also need to be measured to ensure a proper fit.
  2. Templating: Once you’ve chosen a material, the team will create a template of your kitchen layout to ensure the new countertops will fit perfectly.
  3. Removal of Old Countertops: On installation day, your old countertops will be removed, which could take a few hours depending on the material and how it’s attached.
  4. Installation of New Countertops: After removing the old countertops, the crew will carefully place the new ones. This step can take anywhere from a few hours to a full day, depending on the material and complexity.
  5. Sealing & Final Touches: For certain materials like granite or marble, a sealant will be applied to protect the surface. The edges will also be polished, and any seams will be filled for a seamless look.

Overall, the entire process from consultation to installation typically takes one to two weeks, depending on the material and any customizations.

Kitchen Countertop Replacement Cost

The cost of a kitchen countertop replacement varies widely based on the material, size of the space, and installation complexity. On average, you can expect to spend anywhere from $2,000 to $5,000 for a mid-range project. More luxurious materials like marble or granite may push the total closer to $8,000 or more. 

Factors like custom edging, sink cutouts, and backsplashes can also affect the overall price. Be sure to get an estimate from your contractor to know exactly what to budget for.

How to Prepare for Kitchen Countertop Replacement

Wall oven with white cabinets and nickel plated hardware.

Before the installation team arrives, make sure your kitchen is ready for the work. Here’s how you can prepare:

  • Clear the Area: Remove any items from the countertops, cabinets, and kitchen appliances to give the installers a clear workspace.
  • Plan for Kitchen Disruption: Depending on the scope of the project, your kitchen might be unusable for a few days. Make arrangements to cook elsewhere or prepare simple meals during this time.
  • Protect Floors and Adjacent Spaces: Countertop removal and installation can create dust and debris, so cover your floors and nearby spaces to prevent damage.

DIY vs. Hiring a Pro

Custom home remodeling.

While DIY kitchen projects can save money, kitchen countertop replacement, in the long run, is a task best left to professionals. Here’s why:

  • Precision: Countertop installation requires exact measurements and skill to ensure a perfect fit. A professional will have the expertise to make sure everything is aligned and properly secured.
  • Material Handling: Heavy and delicate materials like marble or granite can be difficult to handle on your own. Professionals are equipped to safely transport and install these materials without causing damage.
  • Long-Term Value: A professional installation ensures that your countertops are installed correctly and will last for years to come. Improper installation can lead to costly repairs down the road.

Hiring a professional for your kitchen countertop replacement not only guarantees a flawless finish but also saves you time and stress.

Kitchen Countertop Replacement in Milwaukee, WI

A kitchen countertop replacement is a worthwhile investment that can enhance the beauty and functionality of your kitchen. By carefully selecting the right material and hiring a professional to handle the installation, you’ll enjoy a stunning new space that will last for years to come. 

Whether you want classic granite, modern quartz, or another material, contact us today at Pathway Design Build for a free consultation and we’ll help you navigate the process to achieve your dream kitchen.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *